Published: [Todayās Date]
A side-channel attack is a powerful class of security exploit where an attacker seeks sensitive informationānot by breaking the intended cryptographic schemeābut by studying implementation artifacts such as cache access patterns, timing, power, electromagnetic (EM) emissions, or even sound and vibrations.
In short, side-channels are the āaccidentalā leaks in any computation: tiny data trails left by physical or logical components as they process protected information.
Real-world analogy:
Think of a lock-picking scenario. Instead of brute-forcing the key, you listen closely as each pin tumbles into placeāsound and timing betray information!
Common side-channels:
Why they matter:
Side-channel attacks can subvert even the most mathematically robust cryptosystems, often requiring no software vulnerabilitiesāmerely proximity or access to shared computing resources.
Intel Optane Persistent Memory (PMem) belongs to a new class of memory called non-volatile memory (NVM). Unlike traditional DRAM, which loses its contents upon power-off, Optane retains dataāblurring the boundary between RAM and storage.
Key Features:
A typical Optane system:
[CPU] <---> [L1/L2/L3 CPU Caches] <---> [Memory Controller] <---> [Optane Persistent Memory (PMem)]
^
[Traditional DRAM] ------------------------/
The persistence, high density, and close integration of Optane PM with CPU caches make it an exciting yet complex target for side-channel attackers.
Until recently, most side-channel research focused on DRAM or CPU caches, but Optaneās distinct hardware and new internal cache structure introduce novel attack vectors.
The paper "Persistent State Side-channel Attacks on Intel Optane Persistent Memory" presents the first systematic side-channel security analysis of Optaneārevealing that previously secure assumptions no longer hold, and motivates new defensive strategies.
Traditional memory architectures have a well-documented cache hierarchy: L1, L2, L3 on the CPU, and possibly row and bank buffers in DRAM. Optane PM, on the other hand, exhibits internal, undocumented caches.
The USENIX 2023 study employed microbenchmarking to unveil Optane's buffer architecture. The internal cache hierarchy is roughly as follows:
| Feature | DRAM | Optane PM |
|---|---|---|
| Volatility | Volatile | Non-volatile |
| Row Buffer Size | ~8KB | Line buffer: up to 256KB (reverse-engineered) |
| Buffer Lifetime | Cleared on power | Persistent or semi-persistent |
| Attack Surface | Limited to DRAM | Extended by large, persistent buffers |
The size and persistence of Optane line buffers enable new, high-resolution temporal and spatial side channels.
Prime+Probe is a cache timing attack commonly used to infer access patterns in shared-memory environments.
Because Optaneās internal line buffers are large and persistent, Prime+Probe gains powerful new capabilities:
Practical Implication:
Malware or tenant A could probe Optaneās buffer occupancy, learning which memory regions tenant B is accessingāeven after a crash or reboot.
A crucial step in evaluating security is understanding the hardware. The research paper used timing microbenchmarks to empirically uncover:
Researchers crafted low-level tools to rapidly access (read/write) sequences of memory addresses and record the timings. Variations in timing indicate cache/buffer hits and misses.
import time
import mmap
ADDR = 0x10000000 # Example physical address mapped
with open("/dev/mem", "rb") as f:
mem = mmap.mmap(f.fileno(), 4096, offset=ADDR)
t1 = time.perf_counter_ns()
data = mem.read(64)
t2 = time.perf_counter_ns()
latency = t2 - t1
print(f"Read latency: {latency} ns")
mem.close()
Note: Accessing /dev/mem and physical addresses requires root! Use in a controlled lab environment.
By varying strides and measuring latencies, researchers mapped how many addresses co-reside in a buffer before eviction happensāthus reverse-engineering the cacheās associativity.
Suppose two tenants share hardware in a cloud environment, each using Optane-backed memory. Tenant A launches a Prime+Probe attack on Optaneās line buffers:
Suppose Optaneās buffer isnāt cleared after power loss (or resumes quickly enough for buffers to persist):
For researchers and red-teamers, running your own microbenchmarks is instructive. Below are basic code samples for scanning Optane buffers and parsing timing data in Bash and Python.
#!/bin/bash
# Measure mmap'd memory read times
FILE="/mnt/pmem0/testfile"
dd if=/dev/zero of=$FILE bs=64K count=1 # Prepare file
for i in {1..1000}; do
t1=$(date +%s%N)
dd if=$FILE of=/dev/null bs=64 count=1 iflag=direct 2>/dev/null
t2=$(date +%s%N)
echo "$(($t2 - $t1))"
done > timings.txt
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
with open("timings.txt") as f:
times = [int(line.strip()) for line in f]
plt.plot(times)
plt.xlabel("Iteration")
plt.ylabel("Time (ns)")
plt.title("Optane Access Latency Microbenchmark")
plt.show()
What to look for:
Repeating patternsāa āspikeā in access time usually indicates a buffer miss (eviction by another process).
More advanced tools would allocate a large array mapped directly to Optane PM and access it in patterns calculated to target specific line buffersāthen use timing data to reconstruct the mapping.
Caution:
While useful for research, these actions may violate provider policy on production hardware. Limit to air-gapped, dedicated test environments.
Side-channel resistance is multi-faceted, involving hardware, system software, and application-level mitigations.
Implement cryptographic routines and sensitive data accesses in a constant-time and constant-pattern manner:
Tools and Resources:
As persistent memory technologies like Intel Optane PM scale across data centers, cloud, and AI infrastructure, the side-channel attack surface evolves. The internal buffer architectureāonce ignored as a threat vectorānow warrants systematic attention from both industry and research.
Key Takeaways:
Stay Informed:
Regularly review hardware advisories, security research, and deploy mitigations proactively to keep ahead of attackers exploiting emergent technology side-channels.
This post is part of a series on hardware security and emerging memory technologies. If you found it insightful, share with your team and subscribe for updates on next-generation cybersecurity.
If you found this content valuable, imagine what you could achieve with our comprehensive 47-week elite training program. Join 1,200+ students who've transformed their careers with Unit 8200 techniques.